| Platinum | Billy Birch Pub & Yard |
| Gold | The Old Man |
| Silver | Johnny's Italian Steakhouse |
| Bronze | Jim's Burger Haven |
| Top Pick | Anthony's II Pizza and Italian Food |
| Top Pick | BLUEBIRD Cafe |
| Top Pick | Heidi's Brooklyn Deli |
| Top Pick | Texas Roadhouse |
| Top Pick | The Garlic Knot |
| Top Pick | The Glenn Bar & Grill |